Peer Review Process

JPK Editorial Policy

Peer Review Process

JPK (Jurnal Pancasila dan Kewarganegaraan) applies a double-blind peer-review system to ensure the quality, academic integrity, and credibility of every published article. Each submitted manuscript is evaluated by at least two qualified reviewers with relevant expertise.

Double-BlindReview Method
2 or MoreExpert Reviewers
9 StagesReview Process

The Nine Stages of Peer Review

  1. 01

    Submission of Manuscript

    The corresponding or submitting author submits the manuscript through the online submission system provided by the Open Journal Systems (OJS). To facilitate authors, JPK (Jurnal Pancasila dan Kewarganegaraan) may also temporarily accept manuscript submissions by email.

  2. 02

    Editorial Office Assessment

    The editorial office conducts an initial assessment to determine whether the manuscript is consistent with the journal's focus and scope. The editor also evaluates its structure, organization, language, and compliance with the Author Guidelines.

    The manuscript is further assessed for its basic academic quality and potential methodological weaknesses. Manuscripts that pass this stage undergo a similarity check using Turnitin before being forwarded for peer review.

  3. 03

    Appraisal by the Editor-in-Chief

    The Editor-in-Chief evaluates the manuscript's relevance to the journal, originality, academic contribution, significance, and potential interest to its readership. Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's standards may be rejected at this stage without further review.

  4. 04

    Invitation to Reviewers

    The handling editor invites qualified reviewers based on their academic expertise, research interests, and availability. Reviewers must have relevant knowledge of Pancasila and Civic Education or related fields and must not have any conflict of interest concerning the manuscript.

    JPK applies a double-blind peer-review process: reviewers do not know the authors' identities, and authors do not know the reviewers' identities. The manuscript is therefore provided to reviewers in an anonymized form.

  5. 05

    Response to Invitations

    Potential reviewers consider the invitation in relation to their expertise, possible conflicts of interest, and availability. They then accept or decline the invitation. If an invited reviewer declines, the editor may request recommendations for alternative reviewers.

  6. 06

    Review is Conducted

    Reviewers carefully examine the manuscript, assessing its relevance, originality, methodology, quality of analysis, academic contribution, and clarity of presentation.

    Each reviewer submits a detailed evaluation together with a recommendation. The possible recommendations include acceptance, rejection, or revision (major or minor) before the manuscript can be reconsidered.

  7. 07

    Evaluation of Review Reports

    The Editor-in-Chief and handling editor carefully evaluate all reviewer reports before making an editorial decision. If the reviewers provide substantially different recommendations, the editor may invite an additional reviewer to obtain further academic consideration.

  8. 08

    Communication of the Editorial Decision

    The editor communicates the editorial decision to the corresponding author by email, together with relevant reviewer comments. Reviewer identities remain confidential throughout the process.

    Authors are expected to respond to the reviewers' comments and make the necessary revisions in accordance with the editorial decision.

  9. 09

    Final Steps

    If the manuscript is accepted, it proceeds to the copyediting stage. If revisions are requested, the author must revise the manuscript and submit the revised version to the editor, accompanied by responses to the reviewers' comments.

    Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers for further evaluation, unless they have opted out of the process. For manuscripts requiring only minor revisions, the handling editor may conduct the follow-up assessment.

    Once the editor is satisfied that the manuscript meets the journal's requirements, it is formally accepted for publication.

Editorial Decision and Publication

The final editorial decision is based on the manuscript's academic quality, relevance, originality, and the recommendations provided by the reviewers.

Accepted articles proceed through the journal's publication workflow and are published online. All published articles are freely accessible and available for download in PDF format.